Borderline – Unlikely – Page 5 – Who really belongs in the Hall of Fame?

Dave Trottier

NHL: 1928-39; 11 seasons, 6 quality[1. By modern standards of PPG]
121G, 113A for 234P in 446P; 31.2 PS
Era: Trottier is 14th in Goals, 13th in GPG, 16th in Assists and APG, 16th in Points, 15th in PPG, 16th in Offensive Point Shares, 19th in Point Shares and 23rd in Games[2. Of the 23 players to play at least 400 games between 1928 and 1939]
82-game average: 22G, 21A for 43P
3-year peak (1931-34): 48-game average of 17G, 17A for 34P
Playoffs: 4G, 3A for 7P in 31 games
Adjusted: 210G, 303A for 513P
Adjusted 82-game average: 39G, 56A for 94P
Traded twice at the end of his career.

NHL: 1930-40; 10 seasons, 6 quality[1. By modern standards of PPG]
68G, 136A (24th All Time at his retirement) for 204P in 360 games; 21.6 PS
At his retirement, Romnes was 6th All Time in APG and 25th in PPG[2. Minimum 300 games]
Era: Romnes is 14th in Assists, 5th in APG, 24th in Points and 17th in PPG[3. Of all the players to play at least 360 games between 1930 and 1940]
82-game average: 16G, 31A for 47P
3-year peak (1935-38): 48-game average of 10G, 24A for 35P
Playoffs: 7G, 18A for 25P in 43 games
Adjusted: 117G, 301A for 418P
Adjusted 82-game average: 27G, 69A for 95P
Traded thrice at the end of his career, including getting traded out of the NHL.

Stamkos is active so this post may not be up-to-date mid-season.

Because Kane is active, this post may not be up to date during the season.

NHL: 1925-39; 14 seasons, 4 quality as a forward,[1. By modern PPG standards] all 6 seasons quality as defence[2. By Defensive Point Shares]
140G, 156A (14th All Time at his retirement) for 296P (18th) in 592 games (6th); 47 PS (23rd)
At his retirement, Siebert was 14th All Time in GPG, 10th in APG and 12th in PPG[3. Minimum 500 games, 21 qualifying skaters]
Era: Siebert is 6th in Goals, GPG, Points and OPS, 5th in Assists, APG and PPG, 1st in DPS, 4th in PS and Games[4. Of the 7 skaters to play in at least 550 games between 1925 and 1939]
82-game average: 20G, 21A for 41P
3-year peak (1929-32, playing LW): 44-game average: 17G, 17A for 34P
Playoffs: 7G, 5A for 12P in 49 games
Adjusted: 248G, 503A for 753P
Adjusted 82-game average: 34G, 70A for 104P
If the qualifier is set to 500 games, Siebert is 23rd All Time in Adjusted PPG
Traded thrice.

NHL: 1926-39; 13 seasons, 6 quality[1. By modern standards of PPG]
153G (20th All Time at his retirement), 179A (7th) for 332P (12th) in 582 games (7th); 44.4 PS
At his retirement, Thompson was 13th All Time in GPG, 5th in APG and 8th in PPG[2. Minimum 500 games played, 22 qualifying players]
At his retirement, Thompson was 22nd All Time in Offensive Point Shares
Era: Thompson is 5th in Goals and GPG, 3rd in Assists, 2nd in APG, 4th in Points, PPG and OPS, and 6th in PS and Games[3. Of the 7 players to play in at least 550 games between 1926 and 1939]
82-game average: 21G, 25A for 47P
3-year peak (1935-38): 48-game average of 19G, 22A for 41P
Playoffs: 11G, 11A for 22P in 48 games
Adjusted: 271G, 482A for 753P
Adjusted 82-game average: 38G, 68A for 106P
If the qualifier is set to 500 games, Thompson is 19th All Time in Adjusted PPG
Traded once in his prime.

NHL: 1917-19, 1924-26; 4 seasons, 2 quality[1. By modern standards of PPG]
26G, 10A for 36P in 71 games; 1.5 PS
Skinner never played 3 straight seasons in the NHL
NHL: Playoffs: 1A for 1P in 2 games
Adjusted: 39G, 54A for 93A
Traded within the NHL once near the end of his career, traded out of the NHL in his prime.

NHL: 1926-35; 9 seasons, 5 quality[1. by modern standards of PPG]
106G, 113A (12th All Time at his retirement) for 219P (20th) in 402 games (24th), 31.3 PS
At his retirement, Himes was 10th All Time in APG and 18th in PPG[2. Minimum 300 games, 57 qualifying players]
At his retirement, Himes was 22nd All Time in Offensive Point Shares
Era: Himes is 5th in Goals, GPG, Assists, APG, Points and PPG, 6th in OPS, 9th in PS and 10th in Games[3. Of the 11 players to play in at least 400 games between 1926 and 1935]
82-game average: 21G, 23A for 44P
3-year peak (1929-32): 44-game average of 14G, 18A for 33P
Playoffs: 0P in 2 games
Adjusted: 196G, 335A for 531P
Adjusted 82-game average: 40G, 68A for 108P
Never traded.

NHL: 1930-40; 10 seasons, 8 quality[1. By modern PPG standards]
167G (14th All Time at his retirement), 131A for 298P (17th) in 453 games; 43.7 PS
At his retirement, Dillon was 11th All Time in GPG, 23rd in APG and 12th in PPG[2. Minimum 300 games]
At his retirement, Dillon was 18th All Time in Offensive Point Shares
Era: Dillon is 2nd in Goals, GPG, Points and PPG, 5th in Assists and APG, 3rd in OPS and PS, 6th in Games[3. Of the 8 players to play in at least 450 games between 1930 and 1940]
82-game average: 30G, 24A for 54P
3-year peak (1933-36): 48-game average of 19G, 16A for 35P
Playoffs: 14G, 9A for 23P in 43 games
Adjusted: 288G, 295A for 583P
Adjusted 82-game average: 52G, 53A for 106P
If the qualifier is set to 300 games, Dillon is 23rd All Time in Adjusted PPG
Traded once within the NHL.

NHL: 1917-19; 2 seasons, 1 quality[1. By modern standards of PPG]
10G, 8A for 18P in 38 games; 0.1 PS
When Crawford left the NHL,[2. To play in a senior league] he was tied for the league lead in Games Played but was 20th in Goals, 14th in Assists and 20th in Points
When he left the NHL, Crawford was 25th in GPG, 20th in APG and 24th in PPG
Playoffs: 2G, 1A for 3P in 2 games
Adjusted: 15G, 45A for 60P
Traded once within the NHL, and transferred once, willingly left the NHL, traded and otherwise transferred multiple times outside of the NHL.